Audi A5 vs BMW 428i xDrive
Side-by-side comparison from manufacturer specifications, NHTSA safety data, and live dealer listings.
Vehicles
Vehicles
2016 BMW 428i xDrive
Overview
| Spec | Audi A5Premium | BMW 428i xDrive428i xDrive SULEV |
|---|---|---|
| Selected trim | Premium | 428i xDrive SULEV |
| Body style | Hatchback | Coupe |
| Drivetrain | all wheel drive | all wheel drive |
| Fuel type | premium unleaded (recommended) | premium unleaded (required) |
| Transmission | 7-speed automated manual | 8-speed shiftable automatic |
| Engine type | gas | gas |
| Model year | 2026 | 2016 |
Pricing & market
| Spec | Audi A5Premium | BMW 428i xDrive428i xDrive SULEV |
|---|---|---|
| MSRP | $50,200 | $43,850 (best) |
| Lowest listing price | $11,550 (best) | — |
| Median listing price | $56,310 (best) | — |
| Highest listing price | $63,088 (best) | — |
| For sale now | 57 (best) | 0 |
Fuel economy & range
| Spec | Audi A5Premium | BMW 428i xDrive428i xDrive SULEV |
|---|---|---|
| Combined MPG | 26 MPG | 26 MPG |
| City MPG | 22 MPG | 22 MPG |
| Highway MPG | 32 MPG | 34 MPG (best) |
| Fuel tank | 14.8 gal | 15.8 gal (best) |
Performance
| Spec | Audi A5Premium | BMW 428i xDrive428i xDrive SULEV |
|---|---|---|
| Horsepower | 268 hp (best) | 240 hp |
| Torque | 295 lb-ft (best) | 255 lb-ft |
| Engine size | 2 L | 2 L |
| Cylinders | I4 | I4 |
Size & capability
| Spec | Audi A5Premium | BMW 428i xDrive428i xDrive SULEV |
|---|---|---|
| Seating | 5 seats (best) | 4 seats |
| Doors | 4 (best) | 2 |
| Cargo volume | 36.6 cu ft (best) | — |
| Payload | 992 lbs (best) | — |
| Curb weight | 4,090 lbs (best) | — |
| Ground clearance | — | 5.7 in (best) |
| Wheelbase | 113.8 in (best) | 110.6 in |
| Length | 190.1 in (best) | 182.6 in |
| Width | 73.2 in (best) | 71.9 in |
| Height | 57 in (best) | 54.8 in |
Safety & recalls
| Spec | Audi A5Premium | BMW 428i xDrive428i xDrive SULEV |
|---|---|---|
| NHTSA overall | Not Rated | — |
| Frontal crash (driver) | Not Rated | — |
| Frontal crash (passenger) | Not Rated | — |
| Side crash (driver) | Not Rated | — |
| Side crash (passenger) | Not Rated | — |
| Side pole | Not Rated | — |
| Rollover | Not Rated | — |
| Open recalls (YMM scope) | None reported | None reported |
Highlighted values indicate the better figure for that spec when a clear winner exists. Specs reflect the selected trim for each vehicle. Drag a vehicle header to reorder columns. MSRP and specifications are manufacturer data; listing prices and inventory come from live dealer listings. Safety ratings are from NHTSA.
Trim overview
All available trims with MSRP. The trim selected above is highlighted; comparison specs use that selection.
| Trim | Audi A5 | BMW 428i xDrive |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Premium $50,200 MSRP(Currently comparing) | 428i xDrive SULEV $43,850 MSRP(Currently comparing) |
| 2 | Premium Plus $52,700 MSRP | — |
| 3 | Prestige $56,700 MSRP | — |
Live inventory
Audi A557 for sale
See all
Used2012 Audi A5
2.0T Premium Plus
Moonlight Blue Metallic/Black Roof•Cinnamon Brown75,485 mi$11,550Drive Appeal
Eden Prairie, MN
- New
2026 Audi A5
Premium Plus
Glacier White Metallic•Black13 mi$57,165Audi West Chester
West Chester, PA
New2026 Audi A5
Premium
Mythos Black Metallic•Pearl Beige12 mi$56,638Jack Hanania Audi Jacksonville
Jacksonville, FL
New2026 Audi A5
Premium Plus
Mythos Black Metallic•Black14 mi$57,238Jack Hanania Audi Jacksonville
Jacksonville, FL
New2026 Audi A5
Prestige
Grenadine Red Metallic•Black15 mi$63,088Jack Hanania Audi Jacksonville
Jacksonville, FL
New2026 Audi A5
Premium
Glacier White Metallic•Black14 mi$54,115Jack Hanania Audi Jacksonville
Jacksonville, FL
Audi A5 vs BMW 428i xDrive FAQ
- Which is better: 2026 Audi A5 or 2016 BMW 428i xDrive?
- It depends on priorities. OpenDealer compares 2026 Audi A5 vs 2016 BMW 428i xDrive on MSRP, fuel economy, horsepower, seating, towing, NHTSA safety ratings, and live market prices so you can weigh the tradeoffs.
- Which costs less: 2026 Audi A5 or 2016 BMW 428i xDrive?
- Based on starting MSRP, the 2016 BMW 428i xDrive starts lower at $43,850. Live Audi A5 listings start at $11,550.
- Which has better startingMsrp: 2026 Audi A5 or 2016 BMW 428i xDrive?
- The 2016 BMW 428i xDrive leads on startingMsrp in this comparison (43,850).
- Which has better horsepower: 2026 Audi A5 or 2016 BMW 428i xDrive?
- The 2026 Audi A5 leads on horsepower in this comparison (268).
- Which has better seats: 2026 Audi A5 or 2016 BMW 428i xDrive?
- The 2026 Audi A5 leads on seats in this comparison (5).
- How do the NHTSA safety ratings compare for 2026 Audi A5 vs 2016 BMW 428i xDrive?
- NHTSA overall crash-test ratings in this comparison: Audi A5 (Not Rated/5 NHTSA overall).